Members Login
Post Info TOPIC: A British woman had her prison sentence reduced.


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 2386
Date:
A British woman had her prison sentence reduced.
Permalink   


Laos drug Briton Samantha Orobator has jail term cut

Samantha Orobator
Orobator gave birth to a baby girl after becoming pregnant in jail

A British woman serving a life sentence in the UK for drug smuggling in Laos has had her prison sentence reduced.

Samantha Orobator, 21, of London, lost a High Court challenge against her continued detention but had the minimum term she must serve cut to 18 months.

She claimed she was forced to carry heroin after being raped and should be released because her conviction was a "flagrant denial of justice".

She was sentenced to death but her life was spared after she became pregnant.

'Show trial'

Her lawyers, who argued her human rights had been breached, will now apply to the parole board for her release because she has already spent more than 18 months in jail.

Orobator is currently in Holloway prison in north London along with her four-month-old baby daughter.

She was caught with 1.5lb (680g) of heroin at Wattay airport in the capital of Laos, Vientiane, last August, as she tried to board a flight.

Her lawyers said she was forced to carry it under "extreme duress", but they were never able to offer that in mitigation during her trial.

Edward Fitzgerald QC said two Nigerian men coerced her by taking her passport and threatening to kill her if she did not co-operate.

"They further intimidated her by assaulting and raping her," he added.

o.gif
start_quote_rb.gifIt is important not to jeopardise or undermine the treaties for the repatriation of prisoners end_quote_rb.gif
High Court judgement

Mr Fitzgerald said the case could be described as a show trial and therefore any period of detention based on it would be "unlawful".

Lord Justice Dyson, sitting with Mr Justice Tugendhat, said he was "in no doubt that, by the standards of our justice system, the claimant was treated unjustly in Laos".

He said that if she had been tried in the same way in the UK, a complaint under the Human Rights Act would have been successful.

But the judge dismissed the application, ruling that her case did not satisfy the test of "a flagrant denial" of justice and therefore her continued detention in Britain was not unlawful.

"The test is rightly set very high," he said. "That is because it is important not to jeopardise or undermine the treaties for the repatriation of prisoners which the UK now has with many countries, so that those who are convicted abroad can serve their sentences here.

"[If convicted persons] were easily able to obtain their liberty by challenging their convictions, there would be a grave danger that these important treaties would be set at nought.

"That would be highly regrettable."

Orobator claims she was raped and made pregnant by one of the Nigerian men, but miscarried after "mistreatment" by Lao officials.

The court was told she then became pregnant again in jail by "clandestine artificial insemination", reportedly with sperm from a fellow British inmate.

 

bbc news




-- Edited by khonthakek on Wednesday 20th of January 2010 02:24:37 PM

__________________


animated-graphics247.gif





Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 596
Date:
Permalink   

I'm sick of this topic and " if convicted persons] were easily able to obtain their liberty by challenging their convictions, there would be a grave danger that these important treaties would be set at nought."
so let her go to hell with her british high court !

__________________


Guru

Status: Offline
Posts: 500
Date:
Permalink   

Being a foreigner should never excuse anyone from the law - crime and punishment should be universal to everyone. Thank heavens for the little innocent child that saved her sorry arse, but she should be made an example that foreigners should conduct themselves within the bounds of the law.






__________________


Member

Status: Offline
Posts: 22
Date:
Permalink   

That was odds on when she went back to England, that`s why England have all the terrorists there they can do what they want.

She should have been left to rot in the Laos jail.


__________________
Anonymous

Date:
Permalink   

What a joke! Had she been arrested in Indonesia, Singapore and Malaysia she would have been hung and the British government could have done nothing about it.

__________________
Page 1 of 1  sorted by
Quick Reply

Please log in to post quick replies.

Tweet this page Post to Digg Post to Del.icio.us


Create your own FREE Forum
Report Abuse
Powered by ActiveBoard