Not only Lao copy thai music, but also Cambodian !!!

samakomlao · Guru

Not only Lao copy thai music, but also Cambodian !!!

Date: Sep 4, 2007

Hello all

And thai copied from english and american music, and american and english rock and roll is influenced by african, drums and dances biggrin

Don't you see Bird Thongchai jumping around with YMCA,hands up....etc biggrin

Maybe Thongchai ran out of idea what to sing in his Concert idea

Date: Sep 4, 2007

LOL you all call it "copying"... hasn't anyone ever heard of the word "Influenced" though the last poster used it.

That was Tik Shiro, not Thongchai.

Date: Sep 4, 2007

just think of it as remakes..
copy seems harsh

many people make remakes hehe

Date: Sep 6, 2007

More Khmer versions of Thai songs

"Mah-Tam-Mai"

Khmer version
http://www.palungjit.com/board/attachment.php?attachmentid=16138&stc=1

Bird & Jintara version (Jintara is so cute in this MV)
[youtube=http://youtube.com/watch?v=eGI5vny9x4U]

"Oh-La-Naw My Love"

Khmer version
http://www.palungjit.com/board/attachment.php?attachmentid=51105&d=1133699889

Bird version

evannak · Newbie

well don't say that cambodian copy thai's song without changing. take a look on a song "I think i love you" from Katrya English it is most likely the same as Korean's. or that means thai have no brain as well???? idea

-- Edited by evannak at 06:15, 2007-09-10

Date: Sep 10, 2007

Hello all

Don't you see even famous as Bird Thongchai ran outof idea what to sing in his latest concert. I saw his new Dvd Concert live...they played in the shop, at the beginning Thongchai came out and jumped around and sang ' that's the way i like it' kakakakka biggrin

But I think Aluna, Apac, Log, Cell, Awake....etc they have done well. aww

Date: Sep 11, 2007

I think Copying is can be but those songs there have the copyright. I am sure Lao mucis company or Cambodian also bought the copyright from Thai music company and sang on their own languages.

You guys also copied from you Dad & Mom. If is it good for..why don't we copy from them. It's depend on you guys will choose the best to bring to you, right?

I don't want to see all Laos just only envy or jealous neighbors countries with doing nothing to creating your idea to make our own Laos to grown up.

Date: Sep 11, 2007

I like Thai music. As much as I like Lao music.

Music is the universe.. Music is unlimited of cultural mixed.

Music is the power.. sometime it may lifting you and sometime it may killing you.

Date: Jun 15, 2010

Thai doesn't make original songs
Lao copied Vietnamese songs
Khmer copied Thai songs

Date: Jun 15, 2010

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w6k4pwyLQoo

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LKh71flWvnU

The only difference is that Vietnam bought the copyright from Thai music company and sang in their own languages but Laos and Cambodia don't. Laos can't even accept the fact let alone paying for the copyright.

Date: Jun 15, 2010

Anonymous wrote:

I think Copying is can be but those songs there have the copyright. I am sure Lao mucis company or Cambodian also bought the copyright from Thai music company and sang on their own languages.

You guys also copied from you Dad & Mom. If is it good for..why don't we copy from them. It's depend on you guys will choose the best to bring to you, right?

I don't want to see all Laos just only envy or jealous neighbors countries with doing nothing to creating your idea to make our own Laos to grown up.

Even though some Lao singers might have used some of Thai songs and converted to Lao version, that doesn't mean they were jealous or envy Thai people. It's rather that they were just simply borrowing the songs ideas that's all, and I'm sure Thai did the same for their songs too like " Oduang Chumpa" and some of other Lao songs, I can't think of the top of my head riht now. If you only knew, Lao artists have created their own songs too , so don't you dare discredit Lao artists ok buddy!!

Date: Jun 15, 2010

Date: Jun 15, 2010

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5A_Rl8aQxII

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JQjP4UhntIs

Date: Jun 15, 2010

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x9beHn5B0MU

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y1wkne3nCr4

Date: Jun 15, 2010

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7jpOldBbsRc

Date: Jun 15, 2010

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4m7ePkw3lzE

Date: Jun 15, 2010

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7B0fWhoN4BI

chenko · Veteran Member

^
^
^
Thais didn't copy disney songs. They just have Copyright to make it in thai version.

Not just thai version but there are many versions in other language (japanese , germany ,Norwegian , French, chinese , Thai , indonesian , etc. )

for example look at this!!

-- Edited by chenko on Wednesday 16th of June 2010 09:18:50 AM

chenko · Veteran Member

unlike Cambodian , they don't have copyright but...

-- Edited by chenko on Wednesday 16th of June 2010 03:35:49 AM

Date: Jun 16, 2010

now is no border all three country share almost same language , all three country buddhist , buddhist used sansakrist language to teach buddhist , the reason why all three language relate to one and other , no body copy any body , same as america latin they use spanish language .

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Thai entertainment during 1980s and 1990s also copied a lot Khmer entertainment from 1960s as well. Nobody is perfect.

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Anonymous wrote:

Thai entertainment during 1980s and 1990s also copied a lot Khmer entertainment from 1960s as well. Nobody is perfect.

You are wrong. The songs were originated in Thailand first and then Khmer entertainment compied them. The first song was first released in 1970 and then Khmer entertainment compied it.

and as for the dance you should read the French record about how many Thai dancer were in Cambodia back then 100 years ago.

khonthakek · Guru

samakomlao wrote:

Khmer version

Thai version,

so why not Lao ?

Tic zero , this song was my fovorite, thank you webmaster!!! listen to thai song, Lao No need to copy them!!!and if Lao produces the same song as thai, ppls are ignored to buy it, because ppls would think it's worst.

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

Thai entertainment during 1980s and 1990s also copied a lot Khmer entertainment from 1960s as well. Nobody is perfect.

You are wrong. The songs were originated in Thailand first and then Khmer entertainment compied them. The first song was first released in 1970 and then Khmer entertainment compied it.

and as for the dance you should read the French record about how many Thai dancer were in Cambodia back then 100 years ago.

The khmer song one was relased in 1960s.

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Thai copies songs!!! hmm

Thai version of Where U at from Taeyang

Orginal song

Thai version of Because of You by kelly clarkson

Orginal

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Why don´t we keep on our good work as Vietnam...caz now..they are tryin to hit the Asian market...

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Anonymous wrote:

The khmer song one was relased in 1960s.

It's impossible because the original one was relased in Thailand 1970. but if you do have evidence of the year this song relased in Cambodia please prove me wrong.

The song was written by one of the greatest song writer of Thailand. His name was Paiboon Budkhan (ไพบูลย์ บุตรขัน) (1918-1972). He wrote thousand and thousand of songs that were sung by many and many of Thai singers. Sinn Sisamouth (1932–1976) took this song and sang it in Khmer no wonder why he was famous in Cambodia.

This song was also written by him (ไพบูลย์ บุตรขัน) and relased in Thailand 1947.

http://www.esnips.com/doc/f42a22bb-4882-4afd-a694-0901a772c4e8/ทูล-ทองใจ—มนต์เมืองเหนือ

and here the Khmer version.

http://chuonnat.webng.com/BandamIsan.mp3

so don't tell me that this song is also Sinn Sisamouth's too. Because Sinn Sisamouth at that time 15 years old and wasn't even a singer yet I'm sure. Even today Khmer keep copying old Thai songs.

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Anonymous wrote:

Thai copies songs!!!

So why the hell don't you copy song from Farung like Thai. Oh yeah you already did but you still want to copy Thai song too anyway. Next time just copy song from anyone but Thai.

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Not only Lao copy thai music,but also Cambodian !!!
biggrin

< Also Thai,too .ei....ei.....ei.....> biggrin

TaTa Young
[viedo=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8OpVq00kbo&feature=fvw]
Sarana Young?

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Anonymous wrote:

Not only Lao copy thai music,but also Cambodian !!!
< Also Thai,too .ei....ei.....ei.....>
TaTa Young
[viedo=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=B8OpVq00kbo&feature=fvw]
Sarana Young?

This's real TaTa

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Not only Lao copy thai music,but also Cambodian !!!
biggrin

< Also Thai,too .ei....ei.....ei.....> biggrin

See this Movie-Ong Bak 2

And this movie-Lum Bak 2

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Not only Lao copy thai music,but also Cambodian !!!
biggrin

< Also Thai,too .ei....ei.....ei.....> biggrin

Song-Cha La Wun

Song-Jud Tian Vian Mia

Luffyz · Member

Lao copies Vietnam too

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Anonymous wrote:

The khmer song one was relased in 1960s.

It is as impossible as this one.

Original version

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RpKuhvjHnao

Khmer version

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Y2mtsGFsHA

Some Khmer claim that their version was released on 2001 but the truth is that it was released first in Thailand 2006. but they can just lie to your face lie even about something that can be proved easily like this case.

Date: Jun 16, 2010

Anonymous wrote:

Anonymous wrote:

The khmer song one was relased in 1960s.

It's impossible because the original one was relased in Thailand 1970. but if you do have evidence of the year this song relased in Cambodia please prove me wrong.
The song was written by one of the greatest song writer of Thailand. His name was Paiboon Budkhan (ไพบูลย์ บุตรขัน) (1918-1972). He wrote thousand and thousand of songs that were sung by many and many of Thai singers. Sinn Sisamouth (1932–1976) took this song and sang it in Khmer no wonder why he was famous in Cambodia.
This song was also written by him (ไพบูลย์ บุตรขัน) and relased in Thailand 1947.
http://www.esnips.com/doc/f42a22bb-4882-4afd-a694-0901a772c4e8/ทูล-ทองใจ—มนต์เมืองเหนือ
and here the Khmer version.
http://chuonnat.webng.com/BandamIsan.mp3
so don't tell me that this song is also Sinn Sisamouth's too. Because Sinn Sisamouth at that time 15 years old and wasn't even a singer yet I'm sure. Even today Khmer keep copying old Thai songs.

lol, so Khmer copy everything from Thai. The song was written by him for sure. Thai always think that they never copy other people work. COME ON!!! Just like about Preah Vihear temple, you can see 100% that belong to Cambodia, but Thai people think like the old day everything in the main land of South East Asia is belong to them. Thank to the French to give a true info to about the land.

Date: Jun 17, 2010

Yeah.....I agreed with the guy that said Thai copied from American, and English etc.
For instance, Bird Thongchai:
Don Sornrabiab====copied from Santana Carlos (Black Magic). and Gaolan Yot numta.
Jintala Phoonlab====copied from Lao ( Sao Simuang ) as Sao Warlin. So it's on and on, round & round. There you are, don't just blame on Lao or Camb to copy from Thai OK. my man?

Date: Jun 17, 2010

Sincere person: wrote:

Yeah.....I agreed with the guy that said Thai copied from American, and English etc.
For instance, Bird Thongchai:
Don Sornrabiab====copied from Santana Carlos (Black Magic). and Gaolan Yot numta.
Jintala Phoonlab====copied from Lao ( Sao Simuang ) as Sao Warlin. So it's on and on, round & round. There you are, don't just blame on Lao or Camb to copy from Thai OK. my man?

Noone blame Lao or Cambodia for copy from Thai but you have to learn to pay for it.

Thai got slag off harshly from Lao when Thai didn't pay Lao the copyright and it should go both way.

khonthakek · Guru

Anonymous wrote:

Sincere person: wrote:

Yeah.....I agreed with the guy that said Thai copied from American, and English etc.
For instance, Bird Thongchai:
Don Sornrabiab====copied from Santana Carlos (Black Magic). and Gaolan Yot numta.
Jintala Phoonlab====copied from Lao ( Sao Simuang ) as Sao Warlin. So it's on and on, round & round. There you are, don't just blame on Lao or Camb to copy from Thai OK. my man?

Noone blame Lao or Cambodia for copy from Thai but you have to learn to pay for it.
Thai got slag off harshly from Lao when Thai didn't pay Lao the copyright and it should go both way.

Come on guyz!!!! why are we wasting time to disccus who copies who? as long as they don't break the copy right and the products are good.. we are consumer we are ok for that!!!! blankstare

bip_01 · Senior Member

Luffyz wrote:

Lao copies Vietnam too

You do know that the guy is Vietnamese? And it's called a remake.

Also, Lao doesn't really copy from other countries anymoer if you follow their new music. It's all original. Laos deserves the credits of how much it has improved in producing music in the previous years.

Date: Jun 18, 2010

bip_01 wrote:

Luffyz wrote:

Lao copies Vietnam too

You do know that the guy is Vietnamese? And it's called a remake.
Also, Lao doesn't really copy from other countries anymoer if you follow their new music. It's all original. Laos deserves the credits of how much it has improved in producing music in the previous years.

If you only knew, Lao artists have created their own songs too , so don't you dare discredit Lao artists ok buddy!!

It was what I just said to someone else early on this topic so you and I are

pretty much on the same page.

Date: Jun 19, 2010

THe stater of this topic is Laotian.
Ther person who blame Cambodian is Laotian.

All in all Thai is wrong all the time.

This website is SAMAKOM HATE THAI 555.

Kuck Lai Nor Khon Laos .
Juk Man Yung Dork.

Date: Jun 20, 2010

Anonymous wrote:

Not only Lao copy thai music,but also Cambodian !!!
< Also Thai,too .ei....ei.....ei.....>

See this Movie-Ong Bak 2

And this movie-Lum Bak 2

??????

Date: Jun 25, 2010

khonthakek wrote:

samakomlao wrote:

Khmer version

Thai version,

so why not Lao ?

Tic zero , this song was my fovorite, thank you webmaster!!! listen to thai song, Lao No need to copy them!!!and if Lao produces the same song as thai, ppls are ignored to buy it, because ppls would think it's worst.

+1